Selasa, 23 April 2013

Causality in the Natural Event


The exposition of the Qur'anic concept of causation in the natural events presupposes the elaboration of the Qur'anic concept of creation. It is because causation falls within the structure of the created universe. In fact, the Qur'an has little accounts of cosmogony,[1] but the verses that talk about the creation of everything including man, heaven and earth, and other creature are strewn through the pages of the Qur'an, from which we may be able to grasp the embedded concept of causality therein.

There are different terms used by the Qur'an to express the idea of creation, such as khalaqa, fatara, bada'a, sakhkhara and ansha'a, but khalaqa is the most common term, and has been employed to indicate the creation of everything including man, animals, plants, sun, moon, stars, earth and heaven, spirits and angels. The word faÏara[2] in verb form is used in relation to man.[3] However, the verb form bara'a has not been used to indicate the meaning of creation in the Qur'an, though al-BÉri, meaning the Originator, is one of God's attribute.[4] The same case is with the verb form bada'a.  The term badÊ', meaning also the Originator, has been used only in the context of the heaven and the earth.[5]

The major theme that can be grasped from the verses concerning God’s creation is that Allah is the Creator of all things, there is no creator but He. His creatures are not only things that can be seen with the eye, but also invisible things like Souls, angels, jinns and demons. The way God creates everything is described generally by His sheer command 'Be, and it is'.[6] He created (khalaqa, fatara, bada'a, ansha'a) the heaven and the earth and all that there is between them.[7]  He (God) created (khalaqa) everything[8] and gave to each its measure.[9] One of the focal points that can be derived from these themes is the status of the created ness of the universe with its harmonious order, stability and regularity. When God creates something, He also creates within it the capacity or the limits of behavior, called in the Qur'an qadar or "measure". The following verses are a few examples that describe well the qadar or measure" set in every creature:
Everything functions according to its measure.[10] Indeed, we have created everything with a measure (bi qadar).[11] Verily, Allah has appointed measure (due proportion) (qadr) for all thing.[12] The rain is sent down from the sky according to measure and God causes it to store up in the soil.[13]

It is worth noting, however that qadar or "measure" in the foregoing verses should be understood in terms of patterns, dispositions, trends or in general sense as "holistic determinism". It should be understood neither in terms of particular events and acts nor in relation to predetermination theory. It can also be perceived from the fundamental disparity between God and His creation. The former is infinite and absolute, while the latter is finite and dependent upon the former. Thus, "measured' in this case is best understood as "finite" or "limited".[14]  Moreover, measure in the created things does not imply their independency whatsoever; it conversely indicates their dependency upon God. It is because when God creates things with their measures, he at the same time gives His guidance or command (hudÉ) to them in a continuous way. The Qur'an (al-A‘lÉ 2-3) states, "He Who created [things] and gave order and proportion, and who measured [them] out (qaddara) and thus granted guidance”. Also in The Qur'an (ÙÉhÉ 50)  it is stated, "He gave everything its form and then guided [it]". The following verses should be understood in the same light:
It is He Who sends down rain from the skies, with it We produce vegetation of all kinds; from some We produce green (crops) out of which We produce grain, heaped up (at harvest) out of the date palm and its sheaths  come clusters of dates.[15]

We pour forth water in abundance; We split the earth in fragments; and cause the production of corn, grapes and nutritious plants; and olives and dates.[16]
The measure can also be interpreted as ordained laws,[17] and therefore the whole nature looks one firm, well-knitted structure with no gap, no rupture, and no dislocation.[18] The universe is created in such a manner that it has an ordered and a unified system that works with its own laws, and with natural stability and regularity that have been ingrained in it. Whatever is produced from this creations is already set in due balance.[19] This gigantic machine-like universe, works within ordained laws with regularity and causal processes, not because of itself, but because of the will of its Creator.

Therefore, the causal processes in the nature are designed from the very beginning of creation onward continually. He decrees the rules of causality in everything.[20] Thus, there is no denial of causality, properly understood. If we sow seeds and nurture the saplings, we can expect to reap the harvest, otherwise not. If we build a ship and place it on the sea, and the winds are favorable, we may anticipate profitable trade, otherwise not. The decree for the rules of causality in everything that constitutes an ordered system can be understood as autonomous, in the sense that it works by its own innate laws.

However, it cannot be assumed that after creating everything along with their causal law God gets rest in His throne without creative activity anymore, nor yet does it means that God operates in addition to the operation of man and nature. It is autonomous but is not autocratic, for it does not contain its own final rationale as an integrated part of its being.[21]  In other words, the universe cannot explain itself, has no warrant for its own existence and is not ultimate in itself. Therefore, besides this natural causation there is another causation, which is the ultimate one, from Whom the whole natural processes are originated, that is divine causation.

In addition, the ordered and flawless system of the universe[22], which is usually called "natural sign", is itself a miracle and serves as God's sign for humans. However, since people belittle and ignore them all,[23] God shows His power and capability of diverting, suppressing or temporarily suspending the efficacy of natural causes "If We wished, We could cause the earth to swallow them up, or cause a piece of the sky to fall upon them...”[24]. The case with fire that became cool and safe for Abraham when he was thrown into it to be burnt and also with Moses' rod that turned into a serpent, are the proof of God power of suspending the efficacy of natural causes. This "supernatural miracle", so to speak, is manifested in the hand of the Messenger of God to support the truth of the message he carried out, and certainly, this could never happen without divine permission.[25] This supernatural sign, however, should not be confused with the magic or sorcery, which is illusory, not real and distorts reality. The Qur'an encourages the humans to comprehend the "natural sign" through their reason, but it requires the capacity of faith to understand "the supernatural miracle".





[1]  Fazlur Rahman, Major Themes of the Qur'an, (Minneapolis: Bobliotheca Islamica, 1994), 65-66; Hereinafter cited as Major. Also M.Abdul Haq Ansari, "The Creation of the Heaven and The Earth in the Bible and the Qur'an", in Khurshid Ahmad & Zafar Ishaq Ansari  (eds), Islamic Perspective, Studies in honour of Sayyid Abul A'la al-Mawdudi, (Leicester-Jeddah :Islamic Foundation, 1979), 77-78.
[2]  FaÏara means creation of primeval matter to which further process were applied later. See Lane, E. W. An Arabic-English Lexicon. A lithographed edition, London: Williams and Norgate, 1863); Repr. in 2 vols., (Cambridge: Islamic Texts Society, 1984), v.s. faÏara
[3]  Al-Qur’an,  al-‘AnkabËt 30:30;  HËd 11:51;  YÉsÊn 36:22;  al-Zukhruf 43:27;  al-IsrÉ17:51;  ÙÉhÉ 20:72) and in active participle form (fÉtir) has been used in the context of the heaven and earth ( al-An‘Ém 6:79, 14; ,  YËsuf 12:101;  al-IbrÉhÊm 14:10;  FÉÏir 35:1;  al-Zumar 39:46;  al-ShËrÉ 42:11.
[4]  Even the word al-BÉrÊ is only used twice in the Qur'an (59:24 and 2:54). 
[5]  Al-Qur’an,  al-Baqarah 2-17;  al-An‘Ém 6:101
[6]  Al-Qur’an,  al-Baqarah 2:111;  Ali Imran 3: 47, 59;  al-An‘Ém 6:73;  al-NaÍl 16:40;  al-Maryam 19:35;  YÉsÊn 36:35, 82;  al-Mu’min 40:68
[7]  Al-Qur’an,  al-Hijr 15:85;  ØÉd 38:27;  al-Baqarah 2:116-117;  al-An‘Ém 6:14;  al-‘AnkabËt 29:20.
[8]  Al-Qur’an,  al-Rad 13:16;  al-Zumar 39:62;  al-Mu’min 40:62.
[9]  Al-Qur’an,  al-Qamar 54:49;  al- FurqÉn 25:2;  al-A‘lÉ 87:2-3
[10]   Al-Qur’an,  al-Rad 13:17.
[11]  Al-Qur’an  al-Qamar 54:49.
[12]  Al-Qur’an,  al-ÙalÉq 65:3.
[13]  Al-Qur’an,  al- Mu’minËn 23:18;  al-Zukhruf 43:11.
[14] Fazlur Rahman, Major, 67. A.Yusuf Ali also interprets measure as limitation, meaning that everything has its appointed time, place and occasion. Nothing happens but according to God's law and plan, see Abdullah Yusuf Ali, The Meaning, 1394.   
[15]  Al-Qur’an,  al-An‘Ém 6: 99
[16]  Al-Qur’an,  Abasa 80: 25-29
[17]  See for example A.Yusuf Ali, The Meaning,1636, see note no 6082.
[18]  Al-Qur’an,  al-Mulk 67:3-4.
[19]  Al-Qur’an,  al-Hijr 15:19.
[20]  Al-Qur’an,  al-ArÉf 7:54;  al-Qamar 54:49;  al-Hijr 15:21.
[21]  Fazlur Rahman, Major, 66.
[22]  Al-Qur’an,  QÉf 50:6-7;  al-DhÉriyÉt 51:47-48.
[23]  They say: there is nothing but this present life of ours; we die and we live, and it is only [natural process of ] time that destroy us". Al-Qur’an,  al-JÉthiyah 45:24.
[24]  Al-Qur’an,  Saba 34:9.
[25]  Al-Qur’an,  al-Mu’min 40:78.

Jalaluddin Rumi, Penyair Sufi Terbesar dari Konya-Persia

          Dua orang bertengkar sengit di suatu jalan di Konya. Mereka saling memaki, “O, laknat, jika kau mengucapkan sepatah makian terh...